Monday, December 28, 2009

The American Way of Death Revisited by Jessica Mitford



It may be helpful to note before I even get into this review - or this project for that matter - that I am currently studying and starting to pursue a career in the area of death care, specifically alternative death care guidance. Many of the books that I will be reviewing will be in this area of study. I thought I would behoove me to start with the updated version of "the book" that had the North American funeral industry quivering in their shiny black shoes when it was first published in 1963: The American Way of Death Revisited.

Jessica Mitford, a self-proclaimed muckraker set about to uncover some of the dirty secrets behind the polished veneer of the modern funeral industry in the middle of the last century. Mitford's expose made huge waves throughout the world when it came out and was an enormous best-seller. The version that I read, which she completed just shortly before her own death in 1996, was interesting because she was able to compare and contrast industry changes over the 30 intervening years between versions.

The New York Post said that this book is a "must-read for anyone planning to throw a funeral in their lifetime" and I believe that is still the case - even 15 years after the revisions. Since I am just embarking on my journey into the realm of death care I have been talking to a lot of folks and doing a lot of reading about funerals. This is the book that websites, other books, and random people that I talk to reference as the book that changed everything. I was surprised to learn that my mom and dad both read the original in high school in their Sociology classes. I think it's pretty telling that research done in 1961 could still be relevant today, owing to Mitford's style and the thoroughness of the study.

Mitford, with the aid of at least one full time research assistant, uncovered practices, pricing, and truly abhorrent behavior in the related post-death fields of Funeral Directors and homes, cemeteries, crematoriums, funeral related merchandise and funeral insurance. Peppered amongst the figures and facts are personal stories of folks and their experiences at the hands of corporate or private funeral directors. Speaking of "corporate", that is one of Mitford's overriding themes - the corporatization of the industry is when things went horribly awry. When the 1996 version came out two large companies, Loewen Group and SCI owned 30% of all funeral homes in the country and I wouldn't be surprised if it was more now. Our food, our water, our schools are all commodified, why should our death care be any different?

Since I'm just getting started down this road of study I can not, with any confidence, state whether or not this is the best or only book to read on the subject. However, I am confidant that if you do choose to read it you will enjoy Mitford's style and will benefit from an exercise in examining an industry that grew too fat, too fast. Perhaps you may even be like many thousands of folks so moved that they set about writing their elected officials demanding reform, or joining together and forming cooperative memorial societies.

3 comments:

  1. When my dad passed away I was horrified to find that an obituary published in the Columbian would be $200+. It felt so very exploitative. We opted for an online memorial website in the tune of $35. Dad was cremated, and had requested no funeral-- he wanted a party. Most of the food and drinks for the party were given by family & friends. I am happy that we chose to honor my Dad and not absorb ourselves with which box to have him cremated in, what flowers to order, etc. We bought a big bottle of Jack Daniels for the party and played his music that he had selected prior to his death. I felt that we truly succeeded in a genuine celebration of his life. And it didn't involve a funeral director!

    I would personally love to see a massive change, or revolution even, in post-death commemoration and the elimination of the greedy industry that overshadows it. I'm definitely curious to see what alternative death care entails. I'll be interested to read further about your new venture!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Oh Andrea! Thank you so much for sharing your experience with me. I read the online memorial and it was so beautiful.

    I think that it is so beautiful that you were able to come together as a family and as a community and find a way to celebrate and comfort each other.

    Seeing your profile photo of you with your dad, seeing your messages to him and knowing that the memorial is online reminds me that you are putting that love and those memories out into the webiverse where it's going to be pinging around a whole lot longer than flowers.

    Thank you so much for posting a comment and I am happy that you will be along for the ride!

    ReplyDelete
  3. I loved this review and look forward to reading the book. Hooray for your new blog. I have it in my Google reader and look forward to reading more reviews! xoxo.

    ReplyDelete